As a former student that attended both Carlisle County and Hickman County School Systems, I would have to say that both have several varying yet great attributes. If you want a better classroom experience Hickman County is the way to go, however, Carlisle County is the place for you if you want to excell in athletics. :)
Hickman County High School is a great place to learn. However there are a lot of bullying problems that need addressing. As for the teachers we have some of the greatest most motivated teachers I have ever had the pleasure to know.
I am a former student that is now in the United States Marine Corp and I will say the HCHS is the best school for anyone to attend. I graduated in 2002 and my father ans older brother graduated from HCHS and they would say the same. The teachers are outstanding and HCHS is a type of school were everyone knows everyone.