This is my son's third year at this school and WE could not be happier. This is a school that practices inclusion and diversity within the student population and staff, and doesn't just talk about it. Every child benefits from this model and more schools should model it. Yes, the school has had growing pains, (it's fairly new - 10 years this year) but that's expected when trying to perfect the model and keep to the mission while the school continues to grow and expand. The administration values and considers parents' suggestion each year as to how to improve in different areas as well. The teachers at IDEAL are top notch (each summer, a bio of any new staff member is sent out) and, the staff truly differentiates their manner of teaching between the students, not just in the core subjects but in art, music, dance, physical education, etc. The academics are rigorous and help is always available for those who may need it outside of regular class or school hours. Go tour IDEAL and experience how phenomenal it is for yourself. There's a reason that it's now an accredited school and is a candidate for the International Baccalaureate Program for 6th - 10th grade.
My daughter has a slight learning disability and went to a great private school on the UWS with a rigorous academic program. She managed, with extra work and tutoring, but by 5th grade it was clear that she couldn't keep up. She fell behind, her self-confidence disappeared, and she started to hate school. We were lucky to get a spot at Ideal and changed in the middle of the school year. Not an easy thing to do when you are an 11-year old girl, but it was the best thing we could have done! She was embraced both by teachers and classmates, and within weeks her self-confidence was back and she loved going to school again. The teaching is done at her level, with enough challenge to get to the next level, the individual attention is amazing, and there is real diversity and acceptance of differences. They are starting to implement the IB programme to add a global perspective, and have a great creative arts program. The amount of homework is manageable, and leaves time after school for other interests. I could not be happier with the school and more importantly, my daughter is happy and motivated and her love for learning has returned.
There are essentially two populations at Ideal--special needs kids whose parents are wealthy and can afford the $60K to $100K tuition (or enough money to hire lawyers to sue the DOE for reimbursement), and underprivileged, neurotypical kids who attend Ideal on scholarship (largely subsidized by the wealthy families of sn kids who want their children to attend school with "normal kids.") This is a fine model--except it doesn't work for most sn kids. In order to be cost effective, the school hires the cheapest teachers and staff--turnover is huge. So called experts at the school simply do not have the credentials or background to support the wide range of special needs kids at the school. Parents of scholarship kids typically LOVE Ideal--but it is the sn kids (the very children the school was founded to support) that get the shaft. If you are a parent of a special needs kid and are looking at this school--be forewarned. The school will never share with prospective parents the true turnover rate for these students, but as a parent of a former sn student, I know it is exceptionally high. The school simply does not provide a supportive educational environment for these children.
Ideal claims differentiated instruction but we saw no evidence of this for our child, who has a high iq but delays in social/emotional development. Turnover among teachers is huge and the school lacks the admin to ensure even instruction quality. While some faculty are AMAZING! (such as the art and music teachers) others are surprisingly inept. Communication among parents, teachers and administrators is severely lacking. Our child was in the Zenith program (which costs $58K a year) and with this the school claims to offer ongoing assessment. After receiving little feedback for months, our inquiries regarding our child's progress or even basic questions about curriculum were either ignored or met with a surprising level of hostility for having persistently asked for information. Towards the end of the school year, feedback finally revealed that our child had regressed academically during the year, and shocking, the teachers blamed our child's regression on the very developmental issues that brought us to the school to begin with. One reviewer said the school bleeds special needs kids sadly, we know first hand why. We withdrew our child after one year.
The IDEAL School is amazing. It is innovative and is changing education. The faculty are stellar. Strong creative arts department - music, art, dance - as well as a fabulous tech and robotics program in the middle school. Sorry to see folks who might not have been a good fit complaining here. Come see the school for yourself and you will see a warm, inviting, and rigorous program that helps every child succeed. Very diverse too - a real strength. 60% families of color, 30% students with learning differences. Very accepting and helps students develop a strong identity. A must see!
While The IDEAL School presents a unique and much-needed set of values, the leadership at this school is disgraceful. On IDEAL's own website, it claims that it's "mission" is to develop students who are "responsible" and "compassionate human beings". The leadership team at IDEAL, particularly the head of school, are some of the most unaccountable, ignorant individuals. They have very little idea as to what is actually taking place in the classrooms- both with students and staff. While the school presents an accessible space for children in need, think twice before sending your child into the hands of IDEAL's tyrannical, hypocritical leaders.
As mentioned below, the school does discredit students when they're on the way to transferring; either by not completing applications, recommendation letters or inaccurate grades. Usually the grades are inaccurate because parents are made aware of their childrens' progresses twice per year - no numeric/alphabetic grades. If your child has a special need, any at all, big or small, this is a warm environment that will embrace him/her. The more severe the issue, the better the school will be for your son/daughter. As the school grows, it looks like it has the potential to learn. The staff has favoritism to certain students and parents; while the staff and parents are very clique-ish. Many personal and unprofessional relationships exist among staff and find their way into the conversations of the students. Bottom line: not a place for me or mine. Don't be fooled by the generous scholarship to lure you in.
Not a good school. I would not recommend the school to anyone. If you want to take your child out, they discredit your child to other schools, as in suggesting they have a learning disability. All along you as a parent have never been informed of such.
The Ideal School is a great school for learning. No more than 14 children per class/grade. Very small and supportive education community (everyone knows the children and families). The academic is individual designed for the student. The teachers are very skilled and gifted educators.
My dd loves this school. I'm not as enamored. What it lacks is academic rigor. They talk about differentiated education for all learners, but the admin and faculty have some ways to go in order to truly rep that title. My dd is extremely bright and has some problems being challenged within the school's curriculum. With what she does lack academically, I'm having to compensate with outside resources. It's a bit of a frustration. Challenging academic programs, Ideal does not have. If you're looking for academic rigor, look elsewhere. What I like about the school is the loving, warm, inclusive environment. My dd has grown into an empathic social leader within her community and I know her social and emotional growth is leaps and bounds past what I hoped for her, in the beginning of her career. The teachers and the principal are very personable and obviously care. Sometimes, I feel like I can't get a straight answer but then again, aren't all schools bureaucratic to some extent? It's not a perfect school, but you can see they're trying. It's a young school with growing pains. We're making of it what we can, and if our situation changes, my dd and I will move on.
this school is failure. It has not lived up to it's vision by providing a differentiated education to "all learners". In recent years the school has been bleeding special needs children as the administration found it impossible to address their needs without violating their rights. At the same time some basic needs of general education students have gone unmet.
Our daughter has attended The IDEAL School since Pre-K. Our family feels as though we've become part of a community that is committed to nurture, develop and support our kids. The children hug each other and their teachers in the morning and at the end of the day! The art and music teachers are terrific, the school is growing slowly and deliberately and has maintained an amazingly diverse and high-potential student body. Staff diversity could be better but everyone's the right fit and the head of school has created a culture that listens and values parent partnership.
My child has attended this school for 3 yrs and we love it. It is a very warm and nurturing environment. The principal is on point with pupils as well as the parents. All staff including security provide a great place for learning.. :)
Community ratings and reviews do not represent the views of GreatSchools nor does GreatSchools check their accuracy or verify the reviewers' identities. Use your discretion when evaluating these reviews.
The Community Rating is the school’s average rating from its community members (e.g., parents, students, and school staff). The highest possible rating is five stars; the lowest is one star.
To start a new list, click OK. Otherwise click Cancel.
Thank you! You will begin to receive newsletters from us shortly.
Thanks for verifying your updated email address.
Oops! That email verification link has expired. Please click the button below to receive a new one.
Create an account to submit your answers.
Sign in with an existing GreatSchools account or using Facebook:
Your review has been posted to GreatSchools.
Share with friends! Post your opinion of The Ideal School Of Manhattan on Facebook.
Welcome to GreatSchools!
Thanks! We just sent you an email – please click on the link in the email to post your answers.
Get timely updates for The Ideal School Of Manhattan, including performance data and recently posted user reviews.