Report this review as inappropriate

« Back to compare
/ School Profile
Public charter
New York, NY
Students enrolled: 896
Before care: No

Review topics

This is a safe place to share your honest opinions of a school, whether good or bad.  Learn more.

Success Academy Harlem 1
Develops honesty: Strongly disagree

Posted June 22, 2015
- a community member
This is my son's fifth year at success academy. This school is deceiving parents to believe their children are receiving a private school education when in fact they are NOT! It follows the common core meaning your childs education is solely focused on ELA and Math! History and science are cut mid school year so your children can focus on getting the grades they need to pass the city wide exams just to keep the school in top rank! Our children are guinea pigs of a very corrupt system! The grading system doesn't make any sense. My son was in honors math this year so why is he recieving a 68 as a final grade?You know what your child will get for homework? 45 minutes of reading and a page of math. I've never known a private school to give such little homework, do you? Joy rigor is their motto and neither exsists. When you approach the dean about a situation they are quick to blame you or a child. The teachers are taught to back up the school and never to talk negatively about the school. And believe me many share privately that they don't agree with the schools methods. My son has cried many times for being punshed for not "sitting in sport" they get deductions for everything! Get to many and your child will have their entire 20 minutes of recess taken away! Yes I said 20 minutes of recess! If they are good they'll get 30. This school provides fast track learning! One time my son had to miss his school dance because he had difficulty finishing a writing assignment. It couldn't be extended to the next day because like an office job these teachers have deadlines to submit student work. It had to be submitted the next day. So he gave my son this speech about having to make sacrifices! I cried as I held the new clothes he wanted to change into for the dance. Another time he had to write a 250 word essay in a cafeteria full of people eating thanksgiving feast! If they get to many deductions they must go to detention after school til 5:30pm ! If you value your child having a well rounded education DON'T GO TO ANY OF THE SUCCESS ACADEMY SCHOOLS!

Success Academy Harlem 1 4

Posted February 04, 2015
- a parent
First I'd like to share that each school compliments a different child. A child may excel in one institution over the other but shouldn't define the school where the child unsuccessfully excelled, as lack of... What this school rates high in is frequency and consistency. It is well structured and may differ from the average public school run by the PTA, but there is a systematic format that does seem to work. Parents are able to plan ahead with their child's homework and doesn't really change. It aids in keeping the parent accountable for their child's progress rather than have the dependency of the school to foster the development of the child. Another winning factor is the teacher development and how their educational backgrounds play a role in the classrooms. Success Academy has an infraction system which can teach kids to value their own growth and development while the child tracks his/her own results in following rules. One argument with the school is the absence of language programs which I feel is essential in today's challenging world. Overall this school is designed to challenge children and advise on "make choices".

Success Academy Harlem 1 2

Posted April 04, 2014
- a parent
My son attends this school now and it's definitely a mixed bag in terms of experience. He is definitely learning a lot and I consider the longer hours a good thing - you can't master anything without spending adequate time on it. However, the school seems overly stringent on rules and infractions to the point where my kid is afraid to tell his teacher anything for fear of incurring an infraction. They seem more focused on keeping control of students and watching who follows the rules than encouraging curiosity and imagination. While there is some communication the teacher (I mostly get calls for [questionable] "infractions"), I definitely don't feel like there is any partnership in trying to do what's best for the kids. It seems like communication for the purpose of keeping kids 'in line'. I ask my son every day how school was and his answer is always to tell me how many infractions he incurred that day. And I've heard other kids do the same in the playground. That's sad.

Success Academy Harlem 1 1

Posted February 06, 2014
- a teacher
homeroom teacher still gave him a plain F for the entire semester; there were no phone calls to warn me about his performance, nor was I ever told of any trouble when I would ask his HR teacher if all was well. Also, for the entire semester, scholars were not given any homework! Now, my boy is bright and he got great scores in all of the other classes, he had NEVER gotten an F. Insulted (an F is just abusive), I transferred him to a public school and now he is the best student in his class! I think there is a very high chance this school is guilty of exploitation and that it makes makes unreasonable demands of children which is grounds for child abuse. It looks pretty but it's rotten at the core.

Success Academy Harlem 1 2

Posted September 08, 2013
- a parent
My son went to this school and learned a great deal of things but sadly I had to remove him because he was being bullied. He will get teased for being hispanic, pushed around, personal belongings stolen and thrown in the garbage.These people really didn't care about what was going on with my child. The principal was always hiding in her office in some "meeting". After showing proof that my son was being bullied they didn't care enough to remove the bully from the school or even from my sons class. Please visit the school and interview a few parents before considering this school for your child.

Success Academy Harlem 1 2

Posted December 18, 2012
- a parent
I know with all things there are good and bad. This school (hsa1)has proven true to this fact. While the curriculum is on point there are other aspects of the school culture to be frowned upon. If you are considering any success academies do your homework!

Success Academy Harlem 1 3

Posted October 20, 2012
- a community member
run by a politician who is lookng to make a name for herself and run for mayor

Success Academy Harlem 1 1

Posted June 12, 2012
- a parent
The luck of the draw. Overall HSA has a great educational program and some really good teachers (Mr. Y, Ms. Dugan, Mr. Inslee, Coach Collier, Ms. Bezner, Ms. O). Unfortunately, like most schools HSA 1 aslo has some horrible teachers. Not just horrible in the sense that they do a poor job of imparting knowledge; but horrible in terms of classroom management and communicating with parents. I would highly recommend you make an unplanned visit to the school and see for yourself. To be fair, my son's first grade experience at HSA1 was great, but his second grade experience left much to be desired. On balance, if I had it to do over I probably would not choose HSA 1 and indeed we are considering private school as an alternative to sending him back for more of the same next year. It may take more work on your part at home to replicate the academic achievement, but the are gifted and talented programs throughout the city and you will be sparing your child from being bullied, robbed, degraded and other horrible experiences no child should experience. Complaining to the teachers or administration will only waste your time and make things worse.

Success Academy Harlem 1 4

Posted March 02, 2012
- a parent
My neice has atend this school since the 1st grade. She was pick by lottory. This is a wonderful school with a great core values and very invovled with the children. Thye have a very high academic standard that they hold the students and parents accountable for. if my children where smaller this would have been one of the schools that i would have definitely been proud to apply for.

Success Academy Harlem 1 5

Posted June 28, 2011
- a parent
Harlem Success Academy 1 is truly a school to be emulated. To see that it already has been proves that more need to be created. The teacher, parent and children are all held accountable to their part in process. There are 4 schools in Manhattan, 2 in the Bronx and I believe 2 in Brooklyn. This is proof that the methods and materials used is working. Harlem Success Acadmey 1 should be honored for leading the way on how our children should be taught. Harlem Success stand out as a school all its own. The teachers are well trained and truly go above and beyond your expectation. For a public school, the teaching, guidance and encouragement my child receives is truly a blessing. My son already knows and is preparing himself for his graduation. He know that he is part of the graduating Class of 2024!

Nearby schools

Sign up for email updates

Connect with us

Translate this web page

About GreatSchools

Our mission is to help millions of parents get a great education for their kids. is an independent nonprofit and the leading national source of school information for families. 1999 Harrison Street, Suite 1100, Oakland, CA 94612

©1998-2015 All Rights Reserved. GreatSchools is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization | Ad Choices

Success Academy Harlem 1
34 W 118th St-2nd Fl, New York, NY  10026
(646) 277-7170
Last modified Success Academy Harlem 1 is a Charter school that serves grades K-8. It has received a GreatSchools rating of 10 out of 10 based on academic quality.
Success Academy Harlem 1 Rating: 4 out of 5 based on 34 reviews. Top