« Back to compare
/ / / School Profile
Riverhead, NY
Students enrolled: 225

Contact this school

515 Marcy Avenue
Riverhead, NY 11901

(631) 727-1650
Nearby homes for sale
Map of St Isidore School address.

October 29, 2015
As an educator myself, I have found the curriculum and teaching approach to be head and shoulders above other schools in the area. Not being controlled by common core allows the staff to teach the students the critical thinking skills needed to succeed in high school and beyond. From changing classes hourly and alternating daily schedules to using web based applications for homework and projects, their middle school program stresses the importance of personal responsibility and accountability. In my opinion, these two skill sets are the most critical to a students success in high school. I would give my highest recommendation, and applaud St Isidores for truly preparing its students to become the next generation of spiritual, intellectual and honorable leaders.

- submitted by a parent

October 22, 2015
Transferred in mid school year last year, kids were all so welcoming and friendly. Academically way above our other private school! Teachers are amazing! Great all around environment! Best kept secret in the private school community!!!

- submitted by a parent

September 23, 2014
I have to agree with the student who said that if you are the new kid on the block and not coming in at Kindergarten you will have a very hard time. Just a bit of information for any parent of a special needs child. They don't do special needs as my special needs child teacher said "I don't do special needs" I told her now you do and showed her my child's IEP but from the very first day she wanted nothing to do with my child and made it well known. The principle is new to the school and is trying to do the best she can but does not have much knowledge about special needs children either. Even with the services provided by my school district they were not willing to give my child a chance. The teacher told me she did not belong in her class so I took her out. Now she won't have to deal with my child just my lawyer!!!

- submitted by a parent

November 15, 2013
St isidore, sr linda and the teachers are excellent. 4th year there and it beats any school on Long Island.

- submitted by a parent

January 29, 2013
I am a former student of St. Isidore's. I was there for two years and it was the most miserable two years of my life. My parents wanted to send me and my sister to private school because they thought the education would be better and the classrooms would be smaller. All of us were in for a rude awakening. My sister and I never fit in with the students because we were the new kids on the block while the rest of the students were classmates since Kindergarten. Students, parents, and staff were very cliquey. At that time there was no gymnasium or cafeteria, don't know about now. The principal ran the school like a warden, so did the teachers. It's one thing to be strict but kids have to be kids here and there, not in this school though. The teachers were dull and boring, never enhanced the dry subject matter. Looking back now it is very apparent they were in over their heads as teachers and did it only for the pay. I am currently a college graduate and an aspiring teacher and in no way would I reccomend this school to any parent/child, especially if you are not starting your child from Kindergarten.

- submitted by a community member

March 18, 2012
This School, it's teachers and Sister Linda are a wonderful school. Parent participation is very high and students seem to be a year ahead of the public school in most subjects.

- submitted by a parent

January 28, 2010
I have lived in Riverhead for my entire life. I went to both public and parochial schools. I can honestly say in my dealing with this school, that the principal of the school is wonderful. She truely invests herself in every child, and her ultimate goals all involve what is best for the children. I have seen her go over and above the call of duty on many occasions. Who ever wrote those unkind words about her has a hidden personal agena. The school is a family, and the teachers give extra help to these students dunring their lunch break and after school. It is a nurturing environment.

- submitted by a parent
no rating
January 26, 2010
I have been a part of St.Isidores school for 6 years and could not be happier. To the parents that are disgusted, take your child out, sending your child to St. Isidores is an option and a decision that you make on your own with your family. If you arent happy leave, dont bash the school and its reputation! Yes wee need a gymnasium(which we are working on) and the kids eat in the class but everything else they get from attending this school far surpasses that! They are also working on science labs, remedial rooms(they do offer that now) and a music lab. None of that could be done without parental involvement, so instead of complaining about the parents in the office, get in the office and offer to help. Dont sit on your butt and when things dont happen complain. St.Isidores is an amazing school.

- submitted by a parent
no rating
May 28, 2009
I have 2 children in the school and I am utterly disgusted with many things. First off the principal is very uncaring and no way exemplifies what a nun needs to be she is all about collect money and forming cliques with mothers who come in and 'volunteer' in the office while gossiping. The teachers are there for a pay check and have no interest in teaching the students the work is so behind other schools especially in the middle school level I am forced to take my son out an place him in another school, I have already hired a tutor just to make sure that he is not behind when he transfers to his new school. There is no gym, dodgeball and variations of dodgeball are played mostly, in 4 years my child has not done one art project in 4 years. Save your money and go public school.

- submitted by a parent

December 15, 2008
Former student, now in college. I can't speak to how St.Isidore's has changed since I left, but I can't imagine it being any different. Teachers are forced to teach in subjects they know nothing about and don't have degrees in, while public school kids at RMS have the option of a more intense curriculum and the possibility of taking high school math in 8th grade, something SIS doesn't offer. The environment among students was mostly that of avoiding work and goofing off, since the teachers did nothing to create interest in what we were learning and would often skip ahead several subjects in a class if we were 'behind'. The facilities here are terribly lacking, what with the gym, auditorium, and lunchroom being the the basement. As a parent mentioned, the teachers and parents are very cliquey and cold to outsiders, which isn't very Christian. Not at all worth the tuition.

- submitted by a student

February 21, 2008
My daughter has been in St. Isidore for 9 years (k - 8) and it has given her a terrific foundation. St. Isidore's gives students every opportunity to express themselves under the watchful eyes of the teachers and the principal. The discipline is just right, not too strict, not too loose. I would do it all over again. I'm sure my daughter has been given the tools to succeed in high school and beyond.

- submitted by a parent

August 08, 2007
We love the school, the teachers, principal and staff. My children have and are getting the best education

- submitted by a parent
no rating
May 08, 2007
Academics aren't worth the tuition, and the facilities are terrible. The public school system in Riverhead is far superior, and the administration of St.Isidore's school is hopelessly inept. It's not worth sending your kids here at all, in my honest opinion.

- submitted by a parent

November 08, 2006
Academically this school puts the students ahead of public school kids in the same grade. The children have opportunities to study music through choir, music lessons provided by the school, and the curriculum. The school places a lot of emphasis on sports as well, through CYO,upgrades to the property, and other after school sports. My son, now a third grader, has been in St. Isidore's since kindergarten and loves this school. Unlike public schools in this district, kids get rewards and consequences for their behavior. Teachers are assessed for effectiveness here, and are not kept year after year because of tenure, but because of performance. The Parent Club is quite active, and has real input into administrative decisions, besides being a great fundraising arm for the school. I highly recommend St. Isidore's school.

- submitted by a parent

October 10, 2006
this school is a great school and me being a student from their I made many friends. the staff is wonderful and help the children as much they can. although there is no gymnasium which makes it hard and there is a cafeteria although the children don't use it.. they sit in their classrooms for both lunch and snack! they just put in a new playground which the little kids enjoy, fixed up the fields for softball and the newly added sport baseball, and added soccer nets, and made two new basketball courts. as we speak this school is improving trying to get on top. Sr. Linda (the principal) is doing the best she can she still does many many fundraiser and if you have went to St. Isidore you know your parents aren't thrilled when you come home with a box of chocolate to sell! this school is OK.!.

- submitted by a student

September 12, 2005
Good reputation for a great private school. Very high academically.

- submitted by a parent

August 27, 2005
A religious education is important to me, but not at the expense of the academics. I did like the staff, which makes it hard for me to criticize the school. However, it is important for parents to know what they are getting into. There are only a few musical instruments taught. There is no gymnasium. There are very little extracurricular activities. If your child is exceptionally bright, or needs remedial help, there are no options at this school. Because the school is a small parochial school, they do not have the resources the larger schools have, nor do the teachers have the training that the larger schools give. I sent my child to the school for one year, and felt it was a bad experience overall.

- submitted by a parent

May 05, 2004
We are very unhappy. They do not believe in challenging advanced children. Their gym and art program are pathetic. Lacking a warm christian enviroment. Most of the teachers are wonderful and exceptional, but are held back by bureaucracy within the school. St. Isidore's feels more like a business, than a religious school. Needless to say, my child is no longer attending.

- submitted by a parent
Need help choosing a school? We can help »

Media Gallery

Media missing

Uh oh! No photos. This frame will look much better when you upload photos »

Nearby homes and rentals

Last modified: October 29, 2015

Sign up for email updates

Connect with us

Translate this web page

About GreatSchools

Our mission is to help millions of parents get a great education for their kids. GreatSchools.org is an independent nonprofit and the leading national source of school information for families.

GreatSchools.org 1999 Harrison Street, Suite 1100, Oakland, CA 94612

©1998-2015 GreatSchools.org All Rights Reserved. GreatSchools is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization | Ad Choices

St Isidore School
515 Marcy Avenue, Riverhead, NY  11901
(631) 727-1650
Last modified St Isidore School is a Private school that serves grades PK-8
St Isidore School Rating: 4 out of 5 based on 32 reviews. Top