My child attended this school for several years. During that time I saw favoritism towards students who could sit and work on their own with no help. I saw special needs kids ridiculed, not by other sutdents, and called "stupid." If a child was gifted they were told to not show it as it might offend other kids. If a child struggled or need extra help they were quickly encouraged to leave the school. All the students needed extra tutoring or were behind when they left the school. I witnessed parents who were favored monitor the rest of the parents and report back on actions. We called them the minions. This school was nicknamed "The Communist School." Once we left I was flooded with stories from former parents who left filled with incindents of bullying that was ignored, and bullying by not just the other kids. Parents are required to pay "dues" ever year even though this is a public school. The school is filled with middle to upper middle class white families with few people of color mixed in. I have seen so many children wounded by this school and parents so brainwashed they are afraid to go to another school. It's really sad.
My kids both attended here and have done very well post-Community School (3.9 & 4.0 students in High School). Community School was a wonderful elementary school experience where they learned to love learning and excel at it. The extremely dedicated teachers and parents offer an environment that fosters critical thinking, creativity and striving to always do your best. The playground experience is like no other schools: all grades intermix and play together. There is no-excluding, no bullying. If you want your student in a caring environment that will help them to be academically successful yet at the same time have fun this is the place for them. As a parent you will also be able to participate in the process and feel a part of the community that is like no other public elementary school. This school does not grade or do a lot of homework, especially in the lower grades; don't go here if that is what you want or expect.
Average school. Fun, social environment for the families. But, I agree with earlier postings, academic excellence is not a priority at this school. Expect to spend extra money for outside help or enrichment. This school is not always supportive of special needs on either side of the spectrum - whether your child needs extra help or needs to be challenged. There is an "element of trust" that is needed since there is no testing or report cards or homework. One parent has said, "This is the only school I know where education cannot be discussed." In summary, there are a lot of great things about this school but there is lots, LOTS of room for improvement.
I agree with all the comments below...the good and the bad. No school is perfect. This school has worked well for many families but it has greatly damaged others, and that is why there are so many polarized reviews. Kids who have left, some with much emotional pain, have adjusted well in the regular public schools, but were found to be behind in many subjects such as math and reading comprehension. Academics are not high at this school. Social development is. Do not think this school is better than the regular public ones just because it is a "choice" or "lottery" program. Do your research. Know your kid and his/her needs. While my "above average" kid enjoys this school, please be wary that this school is not for everyone.
My son is a recent graduate. He is dyslexic/dysgraphic. He was always treated with care and respect and was challenged academically by the most dedicated teachers that I will ever meet. He learned to make friends and to be a good friend. To be a good student and to enjoy learning. To work well with others in a group and be determined to excel while working independently. Most importantly, he was given the space and time to figure out how to compensate for his academic struggles that he will have for the rest of his life so that he can be successful. The staff also takes every opportunity to coach kids with behavior situations. Bullying is taken very seriously and from my experience is not tolerated. Community School isn't for all parents...if a parent needs constant feedback and test scores to assure themselves that their child is OK, then CS would not be a good choice. My son is now going to an academically challenging choice middle school where he was moved up a grade level in math, scores very high on the MSP and has great grades. We certainly owe a great debt to the teachers and supportive community at CS for providing our family with a positive elementary experience!
Here is my advice from our experience, for those thinking of attending. If your child is average and doesn t require any extra then the school is a good fit. If your child can educate themselves amidst the chaos, if as a parent you don t need to know where your child is academically at any given point in their time there, and If you are ok with little to no contact with the teachers, then this school is a good fit. If you are willing to pay tutors or enroll your child in extra classes to help keep them at grade level, then this school is right for you! The constructs, the philosophy are ones we could only dream of for our children. The sad part is that it is only this way on paper. After 2 years at the school we decided along with about 25% of the school, to leave. Our child was falling behind in every subject and because there is no assessment or work ever sent home, we did not know what he was doing or where he was academically. We finally had him assessed independently and found he was behind by 1-2 grade levels. This school may excel in the social arena, but you pay for it academically. We hired tutors to help him catch up and moved him to a new school.
Community School offers some great social aspects for children. After almost 5 years at the school we as parents have made great friends and so have our children. I must agree with the posts below that talk about the lack of academic excellence in the school. There is a high number of kids with tutors or in after school classes. There is a definitely a lack of structure and accountability within the school system. I do know that that the current principal is working to improve the situation at the school, but I feel it will be a long process and one that our children will not see the benefit from. I cannot recommend this school if you are looking for academic excellence unless you are willing to pay for a tutor.