HomeImprove Your SchoolTeacher Quality

Emergency homeschooling

When traditional school fails your child mid-year, what's a parent to do? As one desperate mom discovers, there's no place like home.

By Christina Tynan-Wood

I'll just say it: my daughter's school is a disaster. For over a year, I was unhappy with the academics. Then one day last month, an email from my daughter's seventh grade English teacher pushed me over the edge.

Months earlier, the teacher asked us get a copy of To Kill a Mockingbird so students could read it as a class. Note: this was the first time she assigned a book to read — which was alarming in itself. Week after week passed without her assigning a chapter. Finally, via email, she announced, “We don’t have time to read the book. So we will watch the movie.”

I'd been trying to persuade Ava to switch schools for 18 months. A social butterfly who thrives on her friendships, she'd refused. But this incident was too much, even for her. “I want to learn something,” she told me after school one day. “I’m sad about it. But I want to leave.”

I seized my moment. It was too late in the term to switch to another school we liked, but that was no reason to let her brain languish for another four months. The next time I went to the school, it was to fill out the paperwork to transfer her to our home school.

A growing trend

I'm not the only parent being pushed by circumstances to take over my child’s schooling. A 2007 report from the National Center for Education Statistics, found that over half of America's 1.5 million homeschooled students named concerns about the school environment, dissatisfaction with instruction, or other circumstances like health and travel as reasons for leaving their school. And homeschooling is steadily rising: between 1999 and 2007, homeschooling made a 74 percent relative increase.

Rebecca Kochenderfer, senior editor at and author of Homeschooling and Loving It!, doesn’t recommend my hasty start. “It’s best to move thoughtfully, to finish out the term if possible,” she says. But sometimes emergency homeschooling happens. “I’ve seen a lot of it recently,” says Linda Dobson, founder of and author of several books on homeschooling. When things go terribly wrong and you need to react quickly, homeschooling's a good fallback — even if just as a stopgap measure.

Rediscovering a love of learning

Although I acted quickly, I didn't make this decision lightly. You see, I’ve done this before. When my high-school-age son was in the fourth grade, I pulled him out in the middle of the day when his teacher told me she refused to work with him until I put him on medication — even though a doctor insisted he didn't have ADD. I acted out of shock and anger, but it turned out well. Within weeks, Cole rediscovered his love of learning and discovered interests — history, programming — that still inspire him. He studied at home the remainder of fourth grade and all of fifth. This time around, I was ready to home school the minute Ava was willing.

I'm a freelance writer, a life not unlike perpetual graduate school, so incorporating Ava’s education into my day was simple: I set up her own desk in my office and signed her up for online classes at Her classes were live 24 hours after I filled out that transfer form. Her books arrived a few days later. And within two weeks of our “emergency homeschool” decision, she's read several books, is two chapters into writing her own novel, has discovered a fascination with biology (she wears a lab coat to the office) and Native American history (Columbus was a jerk!), and — with a tutor's help — discovered she's quite good at math.

There are dozens of reasons a school suddenly doesn't work for a child and family: bullying, a bored child or one with attention problems, illness, a job relocation, a floundering school district, the lack of funds for private school. “Listen to your child,” suggests Kochenderfer. "....If your child is resisting school, take it seriously. That act of listening can be great for your relationship with your child and for your child’s self-esteem. You can always go back to school. But your child will remember that you listened.”

Next page: Don't burn bridges

Christina Tynan-Wood has written for Better Homes and Gardens, Popular Science, PC World, PC Magazine, InfoWorld, and many others. She currently writes the "Family Tech" column in Family Circle and blogs at

Comments from readers

"I'm not in the rah rah home school camp. Most people I know that are are doing it for religious reasons. I feel those subjects belong in a church, but here we are. Yes there are bad teachers out there, there are also very good ones trying to teach in an ever hostile enviornment. I find this whole situation awfully sad. I wish more people would work with the system instead of against it. Dispite all the feel good comments on here I am willing to bet everyting I own that there are a lot of kids out there not doing very well BECAUSE not all parents are qualified to teach. Nor do they have the time or temperment. I already know some but what to do. I don't know the answers BUT I know there has to be one. "
"Schools are not delivering the standards that many of us expect anymore. We are in a situation where my sophomore child was removed from school due to a mental breakdown. This is the 6th week at home and the San Jose Unified school district refuses to provide home hospital. Discrimination and malicioiusness to the highest degree. My child was formerly a straight A student who could no longer cope with the workloads at school and the negligent administrators who could not "see" the Hidden Disability of depression and anxiety that consumed my child. The U.S. educational system is pathetic at best. "
"I pulled my 7th grader out in Novemeber of this school year because after sitting by watching her come home and haven't learned anything, I was fed up. I don't understand why teachers become teachers if they cannot teach. I decided to also go with and it is awesome. Kids are assigned teachers who they communicate with almost daily but get to control her work schedule and what she learns on whatever days I want her to. Homeschooling is a great idea if parents have the time each day. "
"My children recieved their own books, microscopes, materials and supplies, I recieved the satification they're actually learning. They are no longer bored, bullied or struggling to impress a teacher who flat out doesn't like their job. Virtiual Academy is the best choice ever made for my children instead of figureing out how to fit in they are figureing out who they are without someone telling them there doing it wrong. "
"OK, this article is a little bit one-sided, to be sure. Of the children that are home-schooled, the stats are that about 36% are for "religious reasons." Many of those children, no doubt, are not going to be taught anything about evolution, et al. In my opinion, this a fundamental disservice that those people are doing their children. They are then closing off entire academic opportunities for their children in Science. And perhaps the parents in the above article are capable of adequate home instruction, but many parents are not competent in all academic subjects. Perhaps you have a teacher who is not performing up to your standards, so then maybe it's best to make up for that subject--not take the kids out of the school entirely. BTW--our kid is considered above average and we simply supplement the education he's getting. We don't "home-school." "
"I had to do the same thing this year as well. My child was being bullied by the children at the school and the teacher and Jo adult was willing to put an end to it. So I did. "
"I had to do this when my son was in the third grade. His teacher was mess, and no matter what most of us parents said to the principal about her lack of teaching skills was listened to. Add a learning disability on top of that and it was a baaaad situation. I pulled him out and with the help of a skilled teacher in a learning /tutoring facility I tutored him for the 2nd semester. It was one of the hardest things I ever had to do, to pull him out. It was one of the best things we ever did for his education. We worked in the morning, took field trips and was done by noon most days. "
"Wow, I love this article. I am in this emergency homeschooling situation now. A week ago I signed my son's withdraw paper almost forced by school. I was not ready for anything about homeschooling. This one helps me a lot. Thank you. "
"My son only went to first grade for 3 DAYS I was homeschooling that Thursday. Still homeschooling. I can't stop. Too much fun learning and I am learning much too. "